Best Hotels in Islay

Explore Islay from hotels near iconic landmarks, popular shopping streets, and top dining spots.

Islay House
8.0 (43 reviews)

Islay House ★★★

📍 House, Bridgend, Islay

"This was the worst Airbnb home I have ever stayed in: it. This experience was a blatant example of 1) false advertising 2) breach of baseline health & safety standards of a property that is hosting paying guests 3) disappointing hospitality and customer service. I would not recommend this home to anyone and strongly advise Airbnb ban this host from their platform or at the very least, update the listing to accurately reflect the state of the property. See below for a detailed overview of why the Islay house offered no version of the “comfort of a large home,” “consistency of a luxury hotel” or “conveniences of a 5 start hotel” as outlined in the Airbnb listing. 1. FALSE ADVERTISING - The Airbnb listing spelled out a number of amenities that were not available and oversold the state of the “luxury” historic home. Examples include: a) private beach, b) breakfast baked for the guests, c) Big Kitchen used as a bakery, d) all new heating plumbing, electrics and fibers throughout - Specially on c) the kitchen advertised on the listing was completely inoperable and not even accessible due to flooding and other construction. Instead of the catering size kitchen that was shown in the photos (multiple Arga ovens, counter space, etc), the actual kitchen was a make shift room not a single working oven or stove, leaking commercial dishwasher, dirt and grime on all surfaces, no kitchen knives or prep utensils, and a giant hole in the wall. There wasn’t even a working coffee machine. After raising the issue with the house manager, a new oven was brought in that was also useable due to power issues. The only working device in the kitchen for cooking was a hot plate - Specially on d): there was no heating throughout the common areas of the house, WiFi was barely usable and due to the storm, the power in the dining rooms has gone out. Only upon multiple requests were space heaters provided for the bedrooms and additional lamps provided for some of the working sockets. The only working fireplace to generate heat was a small furnace in the entrance hall 2. BREACH OF HEALTH AND SAFTEY - All throughout the home, the carpets were stained and ceilings cracked throughout due flooding; a number of the bathrooms had mildew, one bathtub leaked and was unusable, and the master bedroom had slugs. I wish the last comment was a joke but beginning on the first night of our stay, we noticed slime trails all over our luggage and sweaters - on the third day, we woke up to a large slug crawling out from under the bed - As mentioned above, the only way to access the advertised kitchen was through a back staircase that had flooded. In order to access the kitchen that was available, one of the entrances led you through a part of the home that the listing describes as “remote, inaccessible and unrenovated.” As such, it was a freezing cold, dark section of the house that incredibly unpleasant to experience as guests who were expecting a safe and light kitchen. 3. HOSPITALITY AND"

Another Place - the Machrie
9.2 (65 reviews)

Another Place - the Machrie ★★★★

📍 Machrie Hotel, Islay

"A very perfect hotel, the best choice for golf lovers, the hotel is clean and the service is thoughtful. I will come again."

Port Charlotte Youth Hostel
9.4 (19 reviews)

Port Charlotte Youth Hostel ★★★

📍 Main St, Islay

"Having never stayed in a youth hostel before and being a single middle aged woman, I was a little apprehensive. I'd booked 2 nights accommodation so I could be near to my friends who were in the adjacent hotel. I was so well looked after by the couple who run the hostel that I soon felt very at ease. My room was comfortable and a decent size with 2 single beds and a sink. All bed linen and one towel are provided. The showers and ladies toilets were just opposite my room so not being ensuite wasn't an issue. Breakfast (paid for separately) was more than sufficient, help yourself to freshly made coffee, toast, yoghurt, fruit, cereals. Milk and coffee also avaliable free of charge if you want to make a drink late at night. The facilities are excellent although I have nothing to compare them with. A very large well-equipped kitchen and dining room and a separate sitting room. All very clean. Other quests while I was there were all adults so I didn't feel an odd one out amongst a lot of youths as I had expected. What a fantastic location too, right on the beach."

Port Charlotte Hotel
9.2 (62 reviews)

Port Charlotte Hotel ★★★★

📍 Main St, Islay

"We arrived on a blustery Sunday evening to a warm hearty kind environment all engineered by the wonderful barman Ross and Jimmy. Ross excelled on his first day taking the first step to becoming a wonderful employee and islander who will never be late to work. His knowledge on whiskey was outstanding I was never led astray by his recommendations and he and Jimmy are an asset to the team. Jimmy mentored Ross all the way to the very end and the camaraderie shown on a busy shift between the two gentlemen was a credit to their mothers. Will come again. Many thanks."

The Bowmore House Bed and Breakfast
10 (42 reviews)

The Bowmore House Bed and Breakfast ★★★★

📍 Shore St, Islay, Bowmore

"Best Bed and Breakfast in Scotland and its not even close. You are treated amazingly well, set up with beautiful accommodation in the most picturesque location. The owners are such a lovely couple who love what they do. Awesome collection of Whiskey which is generously shared."

Glenegedale House
9.9 (58 reviews)

Glenegedale House ★★★★★

📍 Glenegedale House, Glenegedale Isle of, Islay

"Two couples do it. Both are good people. Husband is serious and sincere, wife is kind and kind. It's a short walk from the airport and the bus stop is right in front of you, so the convenience is good and the scenery is perfect."

Beautiful 10 person modern bungalow in Bruichladdich with stunning views
9.6 (26 reviews)

Beautiful 10 person modern bungalow in Bruichladdich with stunning views ★★★★

📍 Bruichladdich

Cozy Cottage In Picturesque Scotland
9.8 (38 reviews)

Cozy Cottage In Picturesque Scotland ★★★

📍 Islay

Guest Reviews for Islay Hotels

8.0
Excellent Traveler Rating
Real & verified guest reviews from around the world
G

Guest User

Other
Islay House ★★★
"Don't be bamboozled. This is an ok place but not luxury. Paint peeling, mold in bathroom, carpets filthy, little to no furniture. It has great bones, but is need of a great deal of refurbishing. The staff are lovely but there is little they can do."
★★★★☆
2025-09-02
G

Guest User

Family
Another Place - the Machrie ★★★★
"Great hotel"
★★★★★
2025-10-18
l

londongirl13

Solo traveler
Port Charlotte Youth Hostel ★★★
"This was a clean and welcoming hostel on the whole but it has a slightly passive aggressive over use of notices. I arrived late (which they were accommodating about). The next morning i made sure to strip my bed and check out by 10 in compliance with the emails I got. i started to make breakfast and suddenly I was breezily told the kitchen was closed for cleaning from 10 to 5 and this was in the emails I received. I had not received emails to say this! this is ridiculous and very unwelcoming. I have not had this experience in yHA. the kitchen was spotless already and didn’t require closing for 7 hours unless you want to get rid of guests. the sitting room was very musty and I have concerns about damp in the building and inadequate ventilation"
★★★★★
2025-08-12
M

MelroseMunchkin

Couple
Port Charlotte Hotel ★★★★
"This smallish hotel has a super location right on the coast with great views across the water. We had a good room with a comfy king size bed and a lovely modern bathroom. It was clean, characterful and well presented with everything you need including free wifi. We arrived at a very busy time (island distilleries open days festival week) but the staff remained helpful, welcoming and friendly throughout our stay. We had dinner in the hotel restaurant which was enjoyable but rather pricy and the seafood was largely overcooked (scallops, halibut). However it was exceptionally hectic so we made exceptions. The excellent skin-on chips with the battered haddock were a joy! Breakfast was also served in the restaurant offering plenty of choice and inviting hot options. Enjoyed our comfortable stay."
★★★★★
2025-05-27
G

Guest User

Other
The Bowmore House Bed and Breakfast ★★★★
"We stayed at The Bowmore House as part of the Scottish Routes 4 day Islay tour. The hosts Andrew and Alison were tremendous. Andrew was most entertaining with his island and whisky knowledge and his sharp wit. The rooms were spacious, clean and well appointed. The breakfast was comprehensive and delicious. A special thanks also to Andrew for looking out for my 82yo father. It was much appreciated. I would thoroughly recommend this place if you're visiting Islay."
★★★★★
2024-09-13
G

Guest User

Couple
Glenegedale House ★★★★★
"Two couples do it. Both are good people. Husband is serious and sincere, wife is kind and kind. It's a short walk from the airport and the bus stop is right in front of you, so the convenience is good and the scenery is perfect."
★★★★★
2026-03-28

Islay Travel Information

Power Plug & Voltage

230V/Type G

💵

Exchange Rate

GBP

💳

Local Payment

Cards/ApplePay/Cash

📱

Connectivity

EE/Vodafone/O2/Three

🌡️

Current Weather

Partly clear with showers

More Information About Islay Hotels

Key Info

Details

Number of reviews

464

Total properties

14

Weekday Avg. Price

Rs 93,760

Weekend Avg. Price

Rs 94,646

Trending hotel

Port Charlotte Youth Hostel

FAQ – Hotels in Islay

  • What popular hotels in Islay have parking?

    If you're planning on driving to Islay, why not stay at Another Place - the MachrieandGlenegedale House ? These are all popular hotels with parking lots.

  • At which popular hotels in Islay can I try local foods?

    Those who like trying local foods might want to consider staying at Glenegedale HouseandAnother Place - the Machrie . There are lots of famous restaurants serving local dishes near these hotels.

  • When traveling to Islay, which hotels have pools?

    Summer is a great season to take your kids or family on a trip to Islay. Another Place - the Machrie is a popular hotel with a pool.

  • Of all the hotels in Islay, which hotels have the highest user ratings?

    When traveling to Islay for the first time, many travelers find it difficult to choose a hotel to stay in. According to Trip.com data, Another Place - the MachrieandGlenegedale House are popular hotels with high ratings, making them good choices for your trip.

  • At what hotels in Islay can I try local breakfast foods?

    A delicious breakfast is a great way to kick start your day. At Another Place - the MachrieandGlenegedale House , guests can enjoy Islay-style breakfasts.

  • What popular hotels have non-smoking rooms in Islay?

    Many guests care about the quality of the rooms they stay in and want to ensure that their rooms have fresh, clean air. Another Place - the MachrieandGlenegedale House are all popular hotels in Islay with non-smoking rooms.

  • In Islay, what popular hotels have free Wi-Fi?

    When staying at a hotel, internet access is important for both vacationers and business travelers. Glenegedale HouseandAnother Place - the Machrie are all popular hotels in Islay with free Wi-Fi.

  • What are the most popular hotels in Islay?

    Whether you're traveling for business or going on vacation, there are many popular hotels to choose from in Islay. Another Place - the MachrieandGlenegedale House are all popular hotels to stay at.

  • What are some popular discounted hotels in Islay?

    There are many popular hotels in Islay. You can find information on discounts and deals here: Trip.com Deals and Promo Codes.

  • In Islay, which popular hotels have gyms?

    Based on Trip.com user ratings, Another Place - the Machrie is a highly rated hotel with a gym.

Disclaimer: This article has been provided by an individual contributor or third party platform. If there is any discrepancy regarding the copyright, please contact us directly and we will delete the content immediately.